הוספת הודעה פורום כתפיים - ראש הפורום

כאב גב תחתון פילטס וזומבה

ד"ר יפתח בר(7.10.2017, 20:28)

שלום

שלום

אין לי ממש ידע אישי בנושא, אך להלן 2 מאמרים שהתפרסמו בעיתונות מדעית . הראשון לא מראה שזומבה גורם לכאבי גב אלא להיפך . כנ״ל גם תרגילי פילטס ( שני המאמרים אגב מאותה קבוצה )

2015 Dec;99(3):211-6. doi: 10.1007/s12306-015-0370-3. Epub 2015 Apr 23.

Is the Zumba fitness responsible for low back pain?

Abstract

PURPOSE:

Zumba fitness requires aerobic repetition exercises, involving the whole body including the spine. Our study is aimed at verifying whether this sport may cause low back pain.

METHODS:

Young healthy females were recruited. They were allocated to a "Zumba group" (n = 25) or an "inactivity control group" (n = 25). The Roland-Morris Disability, the Oswestry, the SF-36 and the Spinal Functional Sort Questionaries of all subjects were measured at the baseline (T0) and at 6 months (T1). During this 6-month study, the number of episodes of low back pain was recorded.

RESULTS:

At T1, improvements were seen in the "Zumba group." The "inactivity control group" showed worsening in each test at T1. The differences between the two groups were statistically significant for the items Role limitations and physical problems, Physical functioning, Pain and Social activity of SF-36 (p < 0.05). There were no any statistically significant differences in either group of episodes of back pain (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS:

We verified that Zumba is not responsible for low back pain. Furthermore, we revealed that Zumba can increase the normal functional activity of the spine. On the basis of this data, we can recommend the practice of this sport on a regular basis for the healthy population, without worrying about the risk of overloading the spine. Further studies are necessary to check whether the patients with chronic spine disease may practice Zumba.

KEYWORDS:

Fitness; Inactivity; Low back pain; Spine; Zumba

2014 Feb;50(1):59-66. Epub 2013 Oct 9.

Daily pilates exercise or inactivity for patients with low back pain: a clinical prospective observational study.

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Studies have shown the effectiveness of a few weekly pilates sessions as helping to reduce lower back pain (LBP). However many patients fear that physical activity can actually make the pain and disability worse.

DESIGN:

We carried out this observational prospective clinical study to look at the effects that taking part in daily pilates has one on side and on the other the effects of LBP management without physical exercise.

SETTING:

The volunteers who participated in this study were recruited from among some local cultural associations.

POPULATION:

Patients affected by LBP were evaluated.

METHODS:

The subjects were 60 volunteers (27 males and 33 females) with a mean age of 51.2 years who had chronic low back pain(CLBP). They were allocated to pilates group (N.=30) or inactivity control group (N.=30). The pilates group performed one-hour lesson of pilates exercise, 5 lessons per week during the following 6 months. The inactivity group continued with their normal daily activities. The Roland-Morris Disability, the Oswestry, the SF-36 and the Spinal Functional Sort Questionaries of all subjects were measured at the baseline (T1) and at 6 months (T2).

RESULTS:

At T2 improvements were observed in the pilates group with increases in physical and social functioning, general health and vitality (P<0.05) and decreases in disability and pain (P<0.05). The inactivity group showed worsening in the same measures at T2.

CONCLUSION:

We found an important improvement of pain, disability and physical and psychological perception of health in individuals who did the daily sessions of pilates.

CLINICAL REHABILITATION IMPACT:

Some authors underlined the possible risk of a lack of adherence to an exercise program at home. This study suggests that a daily pilates program is effective for the management of CLBP. On the other hand, the inactivity contributes to further worsening, inducing a vicious cycle in which pain and physical activity intolerance follow each other.

בברכה,
ד"ר יפתח בר
מנתח בכיר ומומחה לכירורגיה אורתופדית,
פגיעות ספורט וארתרוסקופיה
המרכז הרפואי אסף הרופא